Nueva Italy Pizzeria

Reviews about Nueva Italy Pizzeria

• 3 / 5

  By Cecilia Germaine
  Pizza is good, person taking orders not so much. The delivery person was given the wrong address. Amount "owed" was $5 more than it should have been. Good delivery person was able to figure it out. Doubt if I will order from here again
  May 25, 2017
• 4 / 5

  By Sandrea Maite
  Just found my favorite pizza place. The place is cute and the pizza was perfect. The crust was so thin and crispy with the freshest ingredients ever. Remember it's a BYOB place so take advantage. Get there early and walk around the babe. Definitely on par or better than the other Brooklyn greats, Di Fara and Tortoni's.
  October 23, 2016
• 2 / 5

  By Onesimus R
  Good pizza, just extremely inconsistent. One time delivery took way too long and pizza wasn't hot. Next time we ordered, we gave our address for delivery. An hour later... we called asking for our pizza and it was marked as pick up. Again, no hot pizza. This last time we ordered a deep dish. We ordered extra tomato and so they put nearly no pizza sauce and didn't honor a replacement with good costumer service. They want the bad pizza back. That's fine, it just shows a lack of trust being loyal costumers for 2 years. This will be the last time we order unfortunately. JB's is consistent. I've once had a fallen pizza delivered and JB's made up for it for 2 following orders. Giordanos is consistent. Even Little Ceasars is consistent. There's too much compitition to be dropping the ball. Great pizza, better then the competition. Just dine-in and watch them make your pizza.
  July 26, 2016